LEWISTON, MAINE – OCTOBER 29: Law enforcement personnel stand outside of Schemengees Bar, where one of two mass shootings took place on October 29, 2023 in Lewiston, Maine. Mr. Card, who allegedly killed 18 people in a mass shooting at a bowling alley and restaurant in Lewiston was found dead in nearby Lisbon. (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)
Police who testified before an independent commission investigating the response to a mass shooting in Maine acknowledged missed opportunities to end a manhunt for the shooter that locked down the community and terrified residents.
Maine Gov. Janet Mills and state Attorney General Aaron Frey assembled the commission to review the events that led up to the shootings that killed 18 people at a bowling alley and a restaurant in Lewiston on Oct. 25. The commission has heard from officers with the Sagadahoc County Sheriff's Office and it heard from members of the Lewiston and Lisbon police departments on Thursday.
The shooter's body was found at a recycling facility in Lisbon two days after the shootings. Police had a potential opportunity to end the dragnet a day earlier, officials have said.
But officers did not find anything during a cursory search at the recycling facility the day before the discovery of the body, Lisbon Officer Renee Bernard told the panel.
"We had just started searching that area of Capital Avenue," Bernard said. "Knowing that he had been tied to that location, it was more about seeing if anything there was out of sorts."
While previous hearings have focused on encounters police had with shooter and former Army reservist Robert Card before the killings, Thursday's centered more on the immediate aftermath of the shootings. The Lewiston and Lisbon departments were both involved in the emergency response and subsequent manhunt.
Lisbon Police Chief Ryan McGee told the commission that officers from Lisbon and Lewiston both responded swiftly during the search for the gunman. Police learned that he had an association with the recycling facility and relayed that information to Maine State Police, McGee said.
"We didn't know where he went, but we weren't taking any chances. We were trying to investigate all avenues," McGee said.
The gunman was found dead of a self-inflicted gunshot after the two-day search, police said. Lawyers for victims have also pointed to potential missed opportunities to prevent the shootings in the preceding weeks, as there had been warnings about the man's deteriorating mental health and potential for violence.
More on the Lewiston, Maine, mass shooting
Police who spoke before the commission on Thursday said the response to the shootings and search for the gunman were made challenging by bad tips they received while investigating. They also acknowledged that happens frequently during a major police search.
Other police who spoke described a chaotic scene in the aftermath of the killings in which law enforcement undertook the two-day manhunt for the shooter while petrified residents were locked in their homes.
"We went where needed. Obviously there were still complaints and calls for service coming in," said Lisbon Officer Nathan Morse. "We were just trying to get everywhere we needed to be as quick as we could."
The session with Lewiston and Lisbon police was a late addition to the panel's schedule, officials with the independent commission said. A session with Maine State Police scheduled for next week is still on the calendar, said Kevin Kelley, a spokesperson for the commission.
The commission is expected to investigate potential missed opportunities to prevent the shootings and produce a written report in the coming months. State officials have said the report will be available to the general public as well as the governor and others. Sagadahoc Sheriff's Office members previously told the commission that they had difficulty using the state's yellow flag law that allows guns to be confiscated from someone in a mental health crisis.
In another session, tearful family members of people who died in the shootings called on the commission to make sure others don't experience a similar fate. Kathleen Walker, whose husband, Jason, was killed while rushing the gunman to try to stop him, told the commission: "The system failed."
There were numerous signs the gunman was unstable. He underwent a mental health evaluation last year after he began acting erratically during Army Reserve training. He had been committed to a mental health facility for two weeks and had made threats that he would "shoot up" an Army drill center in Maine. There were also reports that he was hearing voices.
Get updates on what's happening in Boston to your inbox. Sign up for our News Headlines newsletter.
The governor, a Democrat, has announced a series of proposals aimed at preventing future gun tragedies. They include boosting background checks for private sales of weapons and improving mental crisis care. The Maine Legislature's Judiciary Committee has also signed off on a proposal to make sure survivors of violent crime get access to support services.
"I'm eager to see this funded and passed into law, so that these vital services to support victims and survivors of violence can continue," said Democratic Sen. Anne Carney, who proposed the bill.
The independent commission also hopes to hear from Army officials at a future hearing.
